Having coached over 200 Title sales rep and company owners, there is one big mistake they make. You may think that it’s that they don’t call their NDA’s or perhaps they are failing to create content online so their target clients can learn more about them. Nope. The mistake is a simple one, and pretty much ALL of us have done it…including myself. That big mistake is failing to ask for the business. Asking for the business on the phone or in-person. Many Title reps simply don’t do this consistently.
Why They Don’t Ask
In my coaching travels I find the main reason why a Title rep fails to ask for the business is they feel they either haven’t demonstrated enough value in the meeting to ask, or they have fear that the answer will be an objection they have to then overcome. Sound familiar? “It didn’t feel right, or “I will do it next time.” There might not be a “next time.” When the prospect is sitting across from you, that is your greatest opportunity. You have to ask for the opportunity to close their next 2-3 transactions or get your Title Company on 1-2 of their upcoming listings. Otherwise, why else would you be meeting with them? You are there to earn business and get a commitment to do so.
If Title reps simply solved for this problem, it would fix many of the issues they have around not having enough business in the door. It’s like the guy that doesn’t go on many dates with girls, it’s not that he can’t, he holds back when it comes time to ask for the date. Ask more, get more.
How to Ask
There are methods to this as well. For me, it depends on what the prospect is saying in relation to how much of a relationship they have with their current Title Company. If the relationship is fairly strong, then I don’t ask them for all of their business. If you do, there is a good chance you will lose. You are then asking the Realtor to then “choose” on the spot if ALL their business goes to you or their long standing relationship. There are phrases to “gain the commitment” to business. Try these:
- I’d like to earn your next 2-3 transactions to make sure we are a good fit…
- What’s the likelihood of us doing business together in the next X amount of days..
- Of the transactions you have coming up, which one does it make the most sense for us to work on together?
These are just a few ways to ask. Notice I didn’t ask for all their business yet asked for their business? Also, notice I didn’t ask them just for their next transaction. I need at least 2-3 so they can get used to our processes and team.
What’s Holding You Back?
For many, they are thrown into this job with little to no training. They send you out into the field with your good looks and great personality but they don’t “Teach” you how to create clients, a strong value proposition and retain clients. The basis are prospecting for business and asking for the business. Sounds easy, but for many it’s not easy. If this is you, I’d invite you to fill out the form below or reach out to me at Wade@DCTGConsulting.com and we can set up a 20-minute Zoom to see if Title Sales Coaching is right for you.
Let's Talk Title Sales Coaching
Discuss Title Sales Coaching and which program is right for you.
- The Unspoken Major Issue in the Title Insurance Industry - June 30, 2026
- The Biggest Mistake Title Sales Reps Make - September 4, 2025
- Top Title Sales Rep Struggles (and How to Overcome Them) - July 19, 2025






